Shadowheart parents choice. " She chooses to save .

Shadowheart parents choice ”, with this option Neither choice is *wrong* per se, but a point I would make is--Shadowheart is not "letting her parents go", she's *actively killing them*, and in Shar's temple. Both paths will lead to the same outcome with this choice: Shadowheart’s parents will be freed and brought to camp I always figured that killing Shadowheart's parents was the right choice - it's so gentle-seeming, the parents are begging for it, and it seems such a shame to turn down an opportunity to end Shadowheart's questline free of Shar. Players grapple with whether to intervene in Shadowheart’s choices. More digging into Baldur's Gate 3's script files = more of Shadowheart's secrets revealed. Good parents, which SH's parents are, would do anything for their children's happiness. However, in my new playthrough, Should you free Shadowhearts parents? You’re told that, if Shadowheart frees her parents, she’ll continue to suffer from her curse. The dad says no but the mom says Shadowheart needs her parents. During the dialogue scene, you will get a choice “Do not lose your parents, not again. Gather your party and return to the Forgotten Realms in a tale of fellowship and betrayal, sacrifice and survival, and the lure of absolute power. If Shadowheart turned from Shar, she will have a difficult choice to make: save her parents but be forever bound to Shar's curse, or sacrifice her parents and sever the curse at last. They say they want to die to free Shart from the curse, then patch 5 came out and made it loud and clear saving her parents is definitely the best choice. I think saving them and letting them pass are both valid options. Approval rating was at 100. Friend is in the dorm. Let Their Souls Rest: This choice involves letting her parents’ souls rest, severing her ties with Shar once and for all. I talked to Shadowheart's friend USING SHADOWHEART. I felt the wound last night, while you were sleeping. Shadowheart deciding to kill Sharrans is an annoyance, nothing more. They asked for it, and besides the memories Shadowheart had of them are long gone (Loss effect due to being a Shar follower). Nightsong Points are a special approval system, exclusive to Shadowheart. I decided to kill the parents. Whichever choice is made completes Daughter of In Act 3 it's basically going haywire, you can hear SH complaining about the pain a lot). One common theme is her struggle with her faith. Depending on your storyline, this decision can affect her curse, her romance, and her fate. From there, it's assumed that Shadowheart would be tortured and controlled by Viconia DeVir for several decades to come. But from a narrative stand point, I don't get it at all. You skip out of a battle with Viconia DeVir. Her parents are the only link to her past true self. Shadowheart parents mission . She is somewhat happier here but suffers. This will remove the debuff from the Sharran curse placed on Shadowheart and aid you in the final battle depending on the path you chose. Shadowheart may lose her parents shortly after the game and she will still have that wound. If this were a game you played one time for the story and then never again, that would be Shadowheart will also ask you to come with her to a Selunite statue. I chose the "I don't need to tell you what's right" option and she chose to As for me, I thought it was a pretty easy choice to save SH's parents. The Shadowheart Dilemma. You will have a hand in helping her decide. Shar criticizes your attempts, and then the choice becomes clear: if Shadowheart releases her parents, she'll remain trapped by her curse. The more pressing matter, once you head down the steps, will be fighting and defeating Viconia DeVir. Selune and Shar are these incredible sisters who are constantly at odds with each other. As you explore the area, you will learn more about the past Shadowheart, you will find her parents, an old friend and Mother Superior. I just found Shadowheart's parents and was forced to make a choice, or rather, have her make a choice. As for what the moral choice is, that’s going to be up to the individual. Completing Daughter of Darkness will progress Shadowheart story forward. Daughter of Darkness is a Companion Quest in Baldur's Gate 3. at this point, characters with high enough deception can have Shadowheart’s parents write them into their wills, leaving that character their beach house in South Carolina if they die Shadowheart's parents present a difficult choice that is highly influenced by previous decisions, and it greatly affects her character development in Baldur's Gate 3. More posts you may like. And that's why I concur not sacrificing her parents is the better choice. Shar knew the choice she was forcing onto Shadowheart, and with her parents gone it feels like she has taken everything from In terms of combat in BG3, it’s better to kill Shadowheart’s parents. r/GameGuidesGN • BG3 Nightsong Kill or Save Choice. . ¥ÿÿW2¶ Ô\ÕzhFšVœùp~ €´Eõ îï! ª– ñöª ñËo üõÏ ~ààúÿÿÿ †FÆ&¦fæ –VÖ6¶vö ŽNÎ. If she chose to kill her parents, she grieves their loss. Dilemma: What to Do with Shadowheart's Parents. Persuade Shadowheart not to kill her parents. Image: Larian Studios Kill Shadowheart’s parents in BG3 Shadowheart's Choice . Alternatively, Shadowheart can let her parents die so she can be free of Shar’s hold on her. I told Shadowheart it was a decision she had to When Shadowheart reaches the inner chamber, her parents are imprisoned, awaiting their fate. And no matter what you pick she will suffer. I noticed picking up the black diamond will raise a plate, yet no key or button is under it. I wouldn't say companions always do the right thing when left to their own devices. ®nî ž^Þ>¾~þþ3ˬ¿÷åô"ë+,– + &ÇŠVm ÷º¹+ 2iqA ÈEÆÐ1—ãÿ So I finished Shadowheart's personal quest again (this time playing as her) and I have some questions. The Lady of Loss takes another L and SH gains the moral victory, at the cost of a little pain. This walkthrough will 4:55 - End their Suffering9:29 - Save Shadowheart Parents-----Baldur's Gate 3: https://www. The difference between having her kill her parents or save her parents was what kind of answer you choose in my playthrough at least. Why can't we properly save Karlach? Why Second is the same choice about her parents that exists in the good run. Here's a couple lines from the ending I got that convinced me I made the right choice: "There's at least one person who doesn't want me happy - Shar. Shadowheart disapproved of all the good things she did in act one and by the time she was given the decision to do what she wants she stabbed Nightsong. I don't get how denying her In act 3, Shadowheart needs to make an important choice in House of Grief. So I think the ideal would be, give her the noblestalk, save Nightsong, save Shadowheart's parents. Shadowheart wants to be a good person so badly it's almost comical. My Gale ending was so stupid I had absolutely no choice it seems for his ending. Shart cannot fully win, but loss and sacrifice are Shar's domain. This choice in my opinion is way better than letting her parents live. What makes her decide to spare or kill her parents when left to he Whatever you choose, you’ll have to deal with the consequences of your decision, so here’s how to find Shadowheart’s parents in Baldur’s Gate 3. 2024-11-09 00:04. If you choose to remain silent, she decides to kill them. A pair of Dark Justiciars will take away Shadowheart. I will save Shadowheart's parents in that playthrough. In the Shar path, the pain is gone the moment she kills Nightsong, she starts getting power from the curse and using that power hurts her parents in turn. How to defeat Viconia in Umm yeah, thats the whole deal of the decision lol, either Shadowheart parents die and Shar release Shadowheart or they live and they all are gonna remain linked to Shar Reply reply Ahrimel • • if you leave the choice up to shadowheart she chooses to sacrifice them She was raised in a cult of Shar, and her parents were willing to sacrifice her to the goddess. Just want you know, Shadowheart does make her own choice to save her parents in the House of grief if you meet some conditions. He just goes "oh well the crowns in the ocean now. Wether or not that suffering is short or long term is up to Shadowheart. The main difference is that if Shadowheart is a Dark Justiciar when she turns on Shar, Shar restores her memories of every horrible thing Shart ever did to her parents. She seemed to pretty clearly want them to live and her parents don’t put up much of a fight if you say to save them. My choice: I decided to free Shadowheart's parents. For me it comes down to a practical choice for additional gameplay. Both Arnell and Emmeline urge Shadowheart to let them die I'm honestly disappointed with the lack of choice on many ending choices, I get they're meant to be meaningful but it really feels like they're made to be black-and-white just for the sake of it. I did it initially as well and then reloaded to see what the other choice would be (I know, it's a bit cheating but I really wanted to know). In the evil run, if you save her parents, she turns her back on Shar and joins Selune after all, but keeping the dark hair. After defeating the Absolute, they will settle in a quiet Yes but by killing them, you free them. Regardless of what storyline you’ve developed for her, there will be a difficult choice at the end, whether Shadowheart should save or kill her I have a question, I played all the times by giving Shadowheart a choice and she gave her parents to Selune. But that's alright, she's tough enough to handle it. I did it after I visited the armory. ¥ÿÿW1Ž­ Õ^ U Ø8¨³ §vñ† @õ> TµJˆ»Ã^ ¿þøëŸÿþÔÀÆÝ? Œ&³ÅÊÚÆÖÎÞÁÑÉÙÅÕÍÝÃÓËÛÇ×Ïß ¦Yõ÷¹œ^¤VQb €€ C·¥h 0:03 - Selune Shadowheart meets her Parents5:00 - Selune Shadowheart Choice 1 (Kill Parents)9:00 - Selune Shadowheart Ending 1 (Kill Parents)10:25 - Selune S Probably gonna do Selune run again and maybe next time completely free Shadowheart from shar and letting her parents die and stay human for a happy ending to getaway like she was talking I didn't save her parents cause I remained silent, it was her/her parents choice. The Dark Justicar Shadowheart variant of the story makes it even more clear that saving her parents is the ideal choice for her, by the way. yes. It’s quite an emotional moment, followed by an impossible choice that must be made. What are the common themes in Shadowheart fanfic? 3 answers. More specific: They are in Act 3 at the end of Shadowheart's quest. So from what I've gathered, when you let Shadowheart decide the fate of her parents, her decision actually depends on a few dialogs you can trigger, and she will save them if you triggered all three: the tombstone of the Sharran at the graveyard You lose Shadowheart as a follower forever. Her parents can return to Selûne, and Shadowheart, when she pass, can reunite with her family in the Gates of the Moon even if she was not a loyal adherent of Selûne, so long as she actually prays to her. I didn’t really see it as making the choice for her since her parents are the one that tell her to kill them which of course they would since they’re her parents. So, I found Shadowheart's parents and she had her choice to make. How to open the door to Shadowheart‘s parents？ Act 3 - Spoilers In Act 3 House of the grief, I defeated the Sharrans, and realized that SH’s parents are just across a door. They get to pass and be with Selûne. Mechanics influence Shadowheart’s choice, leading to varied outcomes. com/playlist?list=PL_l3 Spoiler free answer: Progress Shadowheart's questline and you should have no issues finding them before the end of the game. And Shadowheart is really the only character that punishes you for being involved. What to Do with Shadowheart’s Parents. Both Arnell and Emmeline urge Shadowheart to let them die I had Shadowheart choose to save her parents without any persuasion on both the Selunite and Sharran paths. By letting Shadowheart kill her parents, that’s the final vestige of Shar’s power in her life gone and she can truly move on. They influence how the encounter with Dame Aylin during the final stages of Act Two plays out, during the quest Find the Nightsong and also have a certain influence on the final decision in the Shadowheart's personal quest. If you let them live shadowheart still has the curse for the rest of her life but can be there for her parents until they die. If you push her to free herself from Shar's curse, her parents will perish. And, to be blunt, I don't think we should really be giving too much weight to her parents wishes in this moment. As we know Shadowheart is trapped by the Shar’s Curse and this creates a lot of hurdles for her, by letting Shadowheart kill her parents, she will become free from the curse forever. her parents get dementia anyways lmao curse of age #2. I've been following her lead, letting her live her truth, being a good supportive romantic partner. I always save her parents because I'd much rather Shadowheart spend the time they still have left together. The game strongly steers you towards killing/"freeing" her parents being the right choice because that's the only way to free her from Shar's curse. This has left Shadowheart with a lot of anger and resentment towards them. shadowheart parents choice. On my evil Durge run where I made nearly every possible evil decision, encouraged her Shar worship, told her to kill the Nightsong (she would save her on her own), and had her on the cusp of taking over the cloister, Shadowheart just had to kill her parents to become Shar's chosen. Find out the consequences of saving or sacrificing them and the possible bugs in the game. Deep spoiler territory: At the conclusion of her quest, in the House of Grief, if you haven't already lost Shadowheart and don't betray her, you fill face off against Viconia and other There is another choice. If you choose to kill Shadowheart’s parents, you’ll gain immense power under Shar, and you’ll also be able to control the remaining Justiciars. The next thing you need to do in the Baldur's Gate 3 House of Grief What do you guys think the best choice is for Shadowhearts parents. Tbh, I am more surprised that the method still works on the Dark Justiciar path. If you spare her parents, she will have to come to terms with their past actions and decide whether she can forgive them. Shadowheart's curse: Shadowheart is cursed by Shar. Dark Justiciar + saving parents is a second chance at redemption, but you lose quite a few lives to get there. I feel like I've missed something major, despite having done pretty much every quest possible in my run. She is a very private individual, but it's apparent her devotion to her deity fuels her journey. Just pick whichever one you think is the best choice for her. Learn the consequences of saving or killing Shadowheart's parents in Baldur's Gate 3. So between these 3 support figures, and a link to the past & present, SH has a much better chance at rebuilding her identity. That's the bad choice. But what else? What is the future with them? In epilog when they are gone - shadowheart travels to waterdeep, fighting sharrans and looking into selunites. Download. So I just entered act 3 and I remember nightspng saying they she will talk to Shadowheart about her parents or something along those lines but I’m not sure if it triggers in act 2 or 3? Related Topics Baldur's Gate Role-playing video game Gaming comment I was leaning towards saving her parents, but in the D&D Lore when a person dies any God linked to them can petition Kelemvor to lay claim to their soul if they want it in their afterlife/domain, and if she keeps a literal Godcurse wound there is a highly likely chance that when Shadowheart dies someday that Shar will petition VERY hard to whisk her soul off to the Shadowfell because the Shadowheart is forced to make the choice of either letting them die and freeing herself of her incurable wound, or freeing them and having to live with the wound her entire life. Alternatively, allowing her parents to perish could break House of Sorrows in Baldur's Gate 3 - a refuge for the followers of Shar, hiding an underground monastery in the Lower City. I will say that, when i eventually go around to playing by female tav playthough. Daughter of Darkness can be acquired from Shadowheart during Chapter One of the first Act. The House of Sorrows is the final point of the quest “Daughter of Darkness”. Her memories will be wiped away, and she'll become a clean slate. Like Wyll chasing after devils in Avernus, she's not shifting the cosmological balance regardless of how good she is at her job. Select the option that aligns with your desired outcome for Shadowheart. A community all about Baldur's Gate III, the role-playing video game by Larian Studios. I want to know one thing though, for the one who saved The whole point is to be cruel and offer a choice in which Shadowheart suffers no matter what she picks. This page includes all possible journal updates listed in the objectives followed by the Walkthrough below including the related . Tl;Dr Shar's curse on Shadowheart doesn't guarantee she ends up in the Shadowfell after she dies, if you save her parents. Shadowheart's choice in the House of Grief in Act III essentially boils down to (a) save her parents and live with the curse for the rest of her life, or (b) rid herself of the curse and allow her parents to die. BG3 is the Shadowheart is number 1. She's gonna make some comments. Once you choose, you will witness the quest’s conclusion. If she leaves them alive - she'll suffer from pain - that much is obvious. I choose additional content. She will then be faced with a tough choice imposed by Shar herself: save her parents or be rid of Shar's curse on her. I get the lesson, I get it. ' and that was her choice. The goddess Shar herself presents the choice: to kill them and be freed from the curse or to save them and endure it Shadowheart act 3 choice spoilers Wanted to see which people picked, a sort of survey/outlook did you save shadowhearts parents or send them into the light Good or evil etc. Is There Any Way to Save Shadowheart’s Parents? Yes, there is an option that can save Shadowheart’s parents. Even though Shadowheart had already "sworn" herself to Shar by killing Nightsong, Shar still cruelly restores all of Shadowheart's memories of her parents and her kidnapping on the spot and tells her to kill them to show her devotion. Act 3 - Spoilers [Edit: I don’t think you guys understand what I’m saying. Should have clarified: in my run i decided to rescue the nightsong in act 2 and in act 3 after the the battle with mother superior you get the choice to either kill her parents ( to cure the curse ) or rescue her parents ( shadowheart keeps the curse ). Unlike the Nightsong thing, this is much more personal with no objectively good or evil choice, so I decided to let her make the decision. Shadowheart's Unexpected Choice OK, so I just got to the part where Shadowheart is supposed to kill Nightsong in order to become a Dark Justiciar . See the consequences of each option and the DC check required to save them. Obviously, you’ll need to find and rescue Shadowheart’s parents. After this, they will be in your camp and able to talk to their daughter. If she rescued them, she sobs that she doesn't deserve to be anyone's daughter for the actions she committed in Shar's name, only for her parents to reassure her that they love her and that she'll always be their daughter. If you choose the answer "This is your choice, Shadowheart. If you let them pass the pain for Shadowheart and her parents end. Yet I don’t know how to open the door. I read the note the Shadowheart left. " She chooses to save In many fanfics, Shadowheart is depicted as grappling with the teachings of her deity and how they fit into her own moral compass. Killing her parents in that path sends them to Shar to be tortured forever to give SH power. 6M subscribers in the BaldursGate3 community. And Shadowheart can choose to kill the Nightsong, so it's not guaranteed that she'll do the "right" choice. Learn how to deal with Shadowheart's parents in the Daughter of Darkness quest in Baldur's Gate 3. Shar is the lady of loss, the silent whisper, in a word: Absence. I chose the dialogue option of 'This is your choice, Shadowheart. If you save them Shadowheart says she finally feels whole and reuniting the family makes me tear up. raμza84 BG3 Shadowheart Parents Choice, Save or Sacrifice. Running this flag will also add the ability for her choice to be to let her parents go free when she sees them after defeating Viconia and being given the choice by Shar. The conditions aren't clear though, it seems you need to take her to the cemetery to see a tombstone as well as to see the graffiti on one of the walls somewhere before entering the House of grief. Without her parents, Shadowheart is In my first Tav run I was going into the game fairly blind and, after I killed Viconia, Shadowheart, when the moment came, chose to kill her parents to end their suffering and break Shar's curse. Shadowheart can live with her parents with Selune once Shadowheart passes, time scales are epic in DnD. Shadowheart’s decision to sacrifice her parents in Baldur’s Gate 3 sparks debate among players. So she has to choose between either saving her parents or enduring Shar's curse. In my opinion, I believe Shadowheart should kill her parents in Baldur’s Gate 3, but only if she’s a follower of Selûne. Keeping her parents alive allows Shadowheart Then take the stairs to visit her secret place. Kill Shadowheart’s Parents. In the House of Grief in BG3, you find Shadowheart’s parents magically chained in She will also kill her parents if you offer her the choice. My first run through of the game and Shadowheart said that she's only just found her parents and wanted to free them. I've done this in previous runs and iirc she normally chooses to sacrifice her parents, but this time she chose to Shadowheart’s Parents Evil Choice . If I let Shadowheart kill her parents, there's no real benefit to the game experience, just some different lines of dialog. I think I still have a save file during that important choice. I convinced Shadowheart to free herself and her parents from Shar. in your opinion wich is the evil/good choice? i think freeing the shadowheart parents is evil choice becuz she then still gonna have the shar curse wich apparently give her excruciating pain every night all night long so she would suffer until she dies so would her parents becuz watching somone you love suffer hurts them just as badly and shadowheart gave a terrified About Nightsong Points [edit | edit source]. I was afraid of the consequences being very heavy but so far it seems that it's "only" the occasional pain with the plus of having her parents at camp and heartwarming dialogues. The whole game revolves around Shadowheart's passionate desire to become a dark justiciar, this supercharged warrior dedicated to Shar, by defeating an immortal being created by Selune (or maybe even Selune's own daughter). comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment. If I persuade Shadowheart to save her parents, I get her parents in my camp along with a lot more interesting dialog. If Shadowheart chose to free her parents, and herself, of the curse, it prevents Shar from getting her grubby hands on them. Shadowheart’s decision reflects complex character development and relationships. There’s no way to get memories back as far as BG3 is concerned. Learn how to save or sacrifice Shadowheart’s parents in the Daughter of Darkness quest in Baldur’s Gate 3. The strongest argument I think there is for letting her parents die is that it is what they want and what Shadowheart chooses if given the choice. Shadowheart doesn't really care about what happens to Viconia after the battle. gosunoob. To clarify what you just said, because maybe you don't realize it, is that you just said you are glad you had Shadowheart kill her parents because living with them would be super inconvenient. Meanwhile Tav knows Shadowheart in the present. You don't need me to tell you what is right. ; The consequences of saving 1. As a result, Shadowheart will be free from Shar's grasp as is the wish of her parents. My second run they turned into moonmotes. Selune Shadowheart + letting parents die was very disappointing for me because she's happier with them alive, physical pain be damned. Letting her do all the trials up to that point still wasn’t enough approval at that point I guess. I just finished Selunite Shadowheart's Act 3 companion quest on my honor mode run, and I opted to let her make her own choice in regards to her parents. There are a total of six Shadowheart is forced to make the choice of either letting them die and freeing herself of her incurable wound, or freeing them and having to live with the wound her entire life. I also preferred the companions' reactions to this option, but I don't Can you save Shadowheart’s parents? You can choose to save Shadowheart’s parents in either path (Shar or Selune). The room it's on the right before you enter the room where the parents are being held captive. Mysterious Our advice on the Shadowheart and Nightsong choice remains the same, as detailed below, but Baldur's Gate 3 has published some relevant bug fixes since launch: Shadowheart is one of the many companions you can recruit in Baldur's Gate 3. if you disguise self and show up as a femme half-elf, you can convince them that you are Shadowheart, you just changed your face magically while on an undercover assignment from Viconia. Finally, as i said before, my Tav will be her new anchor and can help her forge a new future free of Shar. Instead of confronting Viconia, you can choose to align with her betrayed Shadowheart and give her to Viconia. youtube. seoi zie iatk afhmri kzxai qtljpjk uhvcde lsbswn zhvjv ghhj